'God Isn't Fixing This' Argument Divides Even More In Gun Debate
As yet another mass shooting claimed the lives of 14 people Wednesday in San Bernardino, Calif., a familiar refrain echoed from the lips of politicians: Pray.
But for many fed up with the now seemingly routine shootings and the resulting inaction from each over how to stop another tragedy, pleas to God weren't enough anymore.
That was the sentiment New York's Daily News proclaimed on its cover Thursday. With the headline blaring, "God Isn't Fixing This," the tabloid highlighted the tweets of GOP politicians, each asking for prayer following the shooting at an office party at the Inland Regional Center.
An early look at tomorrow’s front page…— New York Daily News (@NYDailyNews) December 3, 2015
GOD ISN’T FIXING THIS: https://t.co/eKUg5f03ec pic.twitter.com/j4gEFg9YtJ
"Prayers aren't working," the paper wrote. "White House hopefuls on the Democratic side of the aisle called for stricter gun laws in the wake of the shooting. ... But after yet another mass shooting in America, GOP presidential contenders were conspicuously silent on the issue of gun control. Instead, the Republicans were preaching about prayer."
The hashtag #GodIsntFixingThis soon began trending on Twitter.
Stand up against violence. Embrace peace. We can do better than this. #GodIsntFixingThis— bobbyp (@bobbyp) December 3, 2015
Dear @SpeakerRyan @tedcruz @RandPaul - STOP PRAYING AND DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT. #SanBernadino #godisntfixingthis— Al McWilliams (@AlMcAlMcAl) December 3, 2015
Sen. Chris Murphy, D-Conn., who called for more gun restrictions after the devastating shootings at Sandy Hook Elementary in his state two years ago, echoed those sentiments.
Your "thoughts" should be about steps to take to stop this carnage. Your "prayers" should be for forgiveness if you do nothing - again.— Chris Murphy (@ChrisMurphyCT) December 2, 2015
Others argued back that God wasn't acting, because he had been removed from schools and the public sphere.
#GodIsntFixingThis ? Maybe because God is constantly getting kicked out of this! Don't need politicians pretending to be believers!— Timothy Henderson (@pragart) December 3, 2015
The passionate online reactions mirror just how divided Americans are on the issue. An October CNN/ORC poll showed the public was split — 52 percent oppose stricter gun control laws, while 46 percent support new ones.
Others thought the online backlash against prayer came across as crass.
"Mockery isn't fixing this. As a supporter of stronger gun control, this New York Daily News cover and the related #GodIsn'tFixingThis Twitter storm make me wince. Only people who agree with me can pray for victims of gun violence?" National Journal's Ron Fournier wrote, adding, "[I]t insults anybody who opposes gun control and demeans their sympathies for the victims. It mocks their prayers. That's no way to win a culture war."
Dr. Russell Moore, the head of the Southern Baptist Convention's Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission, wrote this in The Washington Post:
"Ironically, enough, the 'Don't Just Pray There, Do Something' meme will actually keep things from happening. After all, some of our biggest obstacles to policy solutions of any kind is an ideologically fractured populace where virtually every issue is a test of political purity.
"If you shame away the most human aspects of public life — such as the call to pray for one another — you will find this situation worsening, not getting better. After all, we learn to listen to one another, and even work together, because we see one another as fellow humans, fellow citizens, as people of goodwill, not just as avatars to be warred against on a screen."
Thursday evening, Daily News Editor-in-Chief Jim Rich put out a statement saying the headline wasn't meant to demean prayers in a time of crisis.
"The Daily News' front page is not, in any way, shape or form, condemning prayer or religion. Anyone suggesting otherwise is either — intentionally or unintentionally — misconstruing the point, which is that most GOP politicians have offered nothing but empty platitudes and angry rhetoric in response to the ongoing plague of gun violence in our country," Rich said.
Meanwhile, Texas Sen. Ted Cruz said at the Republican Jewish Coalition conference in Washington that since the shooters in San Bernardino were Muslim it "may be 'yet another manifestation' of 'radical Islamic terrorism,' " as USA Today noted.
Donald Trump also connected the shooting as "probably" related to "radical Islamic terrorism," per NPR's Sarah McCammon, who is at the event.
Guns have become a politicized issue for both sides. On Wednesday before the shooting the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee sent out an email asking people to sign its gun control petition, which takes you to a fundraising page.
The issue is one that will still factor deeply into the 2016 elections. During the 2012 presidential race, the National Rifle Association alone spent more than 10 times as much as gun control groups.
This post was updated at 6:15 p.m. ET with a statement from the Daily News and was corrected at 11:30 a.m. ET on Friday.
Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.